-
SMH: “Opposition grows to filter”
Feb 25 2010, 10:21The Sydney Morning Herald is reporting this morning that the opposition in Canberra to the Government’s mandatory Internet filter is growing:
BACKBENCH MPs on both sides of politics opposed to the government’s internet filtering proposal are vigorously lobbying their colleagues, creating a potential roadblock to the plan backed by the Communications Minister, Stephen Conroy.
A group of four young Liberal MPs – Simon Birmingham, Alex Hawke, Michael Johnson and Jamie Briggs – are leading the charge against the filter within the Coalition, while the Labor senator Kate Lundy is putting a case to her colleagues in favour of an optional filter.
Senator Conroy has won the backing of cabinet and is awaiting debate in the party room next month, while the Coalition is waiting for more detail. With the Greens indicating their opposition, the Coalition’s position is likely to decide the filter’s fate.
Read the full story here. This story confirms what we are also hearing from Canberra; namely that politicians from all sides of politics are increasingly becoming concerned with Senator Conroy’s impractical and costly policy of Government censorship.
It is also worth noting that Tony Smith, the Shadow Minister for Broadband, Communications and the Digital Economy, recently expressed doubts on his blog about the Government’s plan:
The fact it has taken the Minister two years to produce his plan and release results of filtering trials highlights the complexity and problematic nature of his proposal. The Coalition is yet to be convinced that mandatory filtering will be effective.
The Coalition would like an independent audit of the trial results and we hope this can happen as soon as possible.
The Coalition will continue to consult extensively with the telecommunications industry and other stakeholders to enable a fully informed response, if and when the Government puts forward any formal proposal or legislation.
Read more here.
We are hopeful that together the Greens and the Coalition will block this proposal in the Senate, and we look forward to working with politicians from all sides of politics on alternative ways to make the Internet safer for children.













The excerpt you've published from Tony Smith's blog is word-for-word with a section of the response from Nick Minchin to my email voicing my opposition to the filter.
Talk about a party line! Still, I guess Liberal solidarity is either going to make or break this whole thing.
Conroy has been trying to use Goebbels propaganda tips for far too long the problem is hes not nearly smart enough to use them effectively and he doesnt have a leader who is as charismatic. Kevin Rudd's appearance on shows like "good news week" and "rove" have made him look more of a fool than someone in power.
Joking about checking a Canadian's Visa, is not what i want to hear from the pm, least of all any member of parliament, if Rudd wants to joke then i expect clean humour, he is not spared the same leniancy as a comedian. If i wanted a comedian in government, i would vote one in.
Censorship has no right to exist within a democracy, and calling it "classification" is not fooling anyone.
“The most brilliant propagandist technique will yield no success unless one fundamental principle is borne in mind constantly – it must confine itself to a few points and repeat them over and over” – Joseph Goebbels.
Conroy is continually changing what the filter will be, thus his overwhelming failure.
brilliantly insightful story. If only it was as easy to implement some of the solutions as it was to read and nod my head at each of your points
You seem to be very professional in the way you write.`*”".
TX a lot 4 taking the time to handle this, I believe powerfully it and like learning many on this issue. If possible, as you hit expertise, would you mind updating your web log with fewer knowledge? It is exceedingly useful 4 me.
Hello, the blog is great and I love reading your notes. Even though I don’t agree with you at some aspects, that was interesting to discover some other POV, too! Thanks a lot!
It’s a pity you don’t have a donate button! I’d definitely donate to this superb blog! I guess for now i’ll settle for bookmarking and adding your RSS feed to my Google account. I look forward to brand new updates and will share this blog with my Facebook group. Chat soon!
That is a relly good blog! Nice